As U.S. and German officials meet this week to discuss privacy and
security in the cyber realm, a German official is calling recent
revelations of NSA spying on his country the “biggest strain in
bilateral relations with the U.S.” since the controversy surrounding the
2003 invasion of Iraq.
Actually, he said, it’s “bigger than Iraq.”
“Iraq was a disagreement of a foreign policy,” the official, who
requested anonymity, told WIRED. “This is a disagreement of a
relationship between two allies.”
The U.S. State Department did not respond to a request for comment.
Last year, the German news weekly
Der Spiegel reported that the
NSA had been eavesdropping on German Chancellor Angela Merkel‘s mobile phone. The
CIA and NSA reportedly maintained a listening station at the U.S. embassy in Berlin that it used to monitor German government communications.
The German government, outraged by the spying, has reportedly
ended a contract with the U.S.-based telecom Verizon
out of concern that the company might be cooperating with the NSA in
its eavesdropping activities. The government has also sent lists of
questions to the U.S. government inquiring about its surveillance
against German citizens. But, according to
Der Spiegel,
although the NSA promised to send “relevant documents” in response—in an
effort “to re-establish transparency between the two governments”—it
failed to do so.
The spying scandal has come at a particularly delicate time, as the
U.S. is faced with mobilizing support to address issues like the Russian
invasion of Ukraine and the rise of the militant group ISIS in Iraq.
But the German official says the scandal has caused some to call into
question existing perceptions about the legitimacy of U.S. interests in
such matters. “Even if governments agree with the U.S. position, it’s
more difficult [for them] to defend that position to their electorates
now,” he says.
The German official notes that not all European governments share a
dim view of the U.S. in the aftermath of the revelations. Countries like
Germany with a recent history of authoritarianism are more sensitive to
the surveillance issue than those with a longer history of democracy,
he says, because they have a greater wariness of state institutions and
control.
“They distrust the state [in general] and they want to make sure that
they control the state and not that the state controls them,” he says.
“In all of Europe, with the exception of Belarus, you have solid
democracies. But in some of those, you have relatively recent
authoritarianism.”
Another European official told WIRED the spying is likely to affect
international commerce, particularly trade agreements, going forward.
European countries that have other issues with regard to trade
negotiations with the United States likely will use the spying as
leverage to gain an upper hand in those negotiations, he says.
“The Snowden revelations have a tremendous effect on how the U.S. is
seen [in Europe],” he says. “It will be very difficult to disentangle
[other issues from this] and will be harder to get consensus on trade.”
This aside, the meetings between U.S. and German officials this week
were designed in part to address the strain between the two countries.
They met in
open and closed-door meetings
on Thursday and Friday to discuss a number of cyber issues. The open
meeting included German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier,
senior White House advisor John Podesta,
as well as other members of government, industry, and academia. Its aim
was to focus, in part, on establishing cooperation between the two
countries with regard to securing critical infrastructure and addressing
cyber crime. But the issue of U.S. spying loomed large over this and
the closed-door proceedings.
The German official said the meetings were being viewed as an
opportunity to establish understanding of the issues and, with regard to
the spying scandal, “identify ways to move on” and attempt to repair
the damage that’s been done by the surveillance.
The overall goal, he said, “is not to ruin what has been a beautiful friendship since 1947, but to try to fix this.”